Which 3-Row SUV Won the 2016 Comparison Test Based on Family-Friendly Features and Value?

The 2016 Honda Pilot scored a decisive victory with 782 points in a rigorous eight-SUV comparison, outperforming rivals like the GMC Acadia and Kia Sorento by focusing on minivan-like practicality in an SUV body. Judged by automotive experts and a real-world family, the test evaluated vehicles under $45,000 with a minimum EPA combined rating of 19 mpg. The winning Pilot distinguished itself with exceptional storage solutions, versatile seating, and a reputation for reliability that resonated strongly with family shoppers.

What Were the Key Strengths of the Top-Ranked Honda Pilot?

The Honda Pilot's win was anchored in its unmatched family-centric design and thoughtful features. Our assessment experience confirmed it offers minivan-level practicality without the minivan styling. Key advantages included:

• Abundant Storage Space: The Pilot features a massive center console bin, dual-level front door pockets, and numerous nooks for loose items, making it a storage champion.
• Versatile Seating: A one-button system folds and slides the second-row seats forward for easy third-row access. Notably, it was the only SUV in the test that could fit three car seats across the second row.
• Excellent Visibility: Large windows and a clear rear view addressed a common complaint in the segment, with the LaneWatch blind-spot camera system providing an extra layer of safety.
• Comprehensive Connectivity: With multiple USB ports and power outlets throughout the cabin, the Pilot ensured all family devices remained charged.

However, judges noted drawbacks, including a frustrating push-button gear selector and a nine-speed automatic transmission that sometimes exhibited a delay when accelerating. The touchscreen multimedia system also drew criticism for its lack of physical knobs for volume and tuning.

How Did the Other SUVs Compare in Terms of Value and Performance?

The competitors were ranked based on scores from expert judges (72%), family shoppers (18%), and a real-world fuel economy drive (10%). Here’s how they stacked up:

2. 2017 GMC Acadia (763 points) Praised for its agile handling and strong V-6 engine, the redesigned Acadia offered an upscale interior. However, its downsized dimensions resulted in limited third-row legroom and minimal cargo space behind the third row, hurting its utility score.

3. 2017 Kia Sorento (735 points) The Sorento impressed with a comfortable, quiet ride and a long list of standard features for the price, including advanced safety tech. Its main flaws were a cramped third row and the smallest cargo capacity in the test with all seats in use.

4. 2016 Mazda CX-9 (715 points) Standing out for its premium interior and engaging driving dynamics, the CX-9’s turbocharged four-cylinder engine balanced power and efficiency. Its significant compromise was a very tight third-row seat suitable only for small children on short trips.

5. 2017 Dodge Durango (702 points) The Durango boasted best-in-class towing capacity and a powerful V-6 engine. Its truck-based roots, however, translated to a less refined ride and lower fuel economy than its car-based competitors.

6. 2017 Ford Explorer (693 points) The Explorer's major upgrade was its highly praised Sync 3 multimedia system and a clever, flat-folding third row. It was let down by a cramped driver's footwell and a lack of rear-seat charging ports.

7. 2017 Hyundai Santa Fe (689 points) The Santa Fe represented exceptional value, offering features like a panoramic sunroof and a 360-degree camera at a competitive price. Judges found it lagged in ride refinement and rear visibility.

8. 2017 Nissan Pathfinder (655 points) The Pathfinder scored points for a comfortable, airy cabin and easy third-row access. It finished last due to a dated interior, continuously variable transmission (CVT) that was often noisy, and a lack of standard features expected at its price point.

What Practical Advice Can Shoppers Take From This Test?

For families prioritizing space and reliability, the Honda Pilot remains a top contender based on its decisive victory. However, the "best" SUV often depends on specific needs. Here is a summary to guide your decision:

When shopping, focus on your non-negotiable needs. If you frequently use the third row, prioritize models with easy access and comfortable seating. If cargo space is critical, verify cubic footage behind the third row. Always conduct a thorough test drive to assess real-world comfort, transmission behavior, and multimedia system usability.