Browse
Log in / Register
Share
The 2018 Volkswagen Atlas is the definitive winner in a head-to-head comparison of four popular three-row SUVs, outperforming rivals from Honda, Chevrolet, and Toyota in key areas like interior space, technology, and overall value. Based on a rigorous test by automotive experts that scored vehicles across 14 categories, the Atlas secured a decisive victory, proving that newer competitors are raising the bar for family haulers.
For families prioritizing space, comfort, and modern features, the three-row SUV segment offers compelling alternatives to minivans. This professional comparison, conducted with a price cap of $46,000, evaluated the 2018 Volkswagen Atlas, 2018 Chevrolet Traverse, 2017 Honda Pilot, and 2017 Toyota Highlander. The results provide a clear hierarchy for shoppers, with the Atlas emerging as the top recommendation.
The SUVs were ranked based on a cumulative point system from four judges, including an in-market shopper. Points were awarded for interior quality, comfort for all three rows, cargo space, powertrain performance, multimedia systems, and advanced safety features.
| SUV Model | Total Points | Key Strengths |
|---|---|---|
| 2018 Volkswagen Atlas | 778 | Top-rated multimedia, best third-row, excellent safety tech |
| 2018 Chevrolet Traverse | 680 | Spacious cargo area, comfortable ride, powerful V-6 |
| 2017 Honda Pilot | 674 | Quiet cabin, great visibility, versatile storage |
| 2017 Toyota Highlander | 559 | Standard safety features, comfortable front seats |
The final scores reveal a significant gap between the top and bottom contenders, highlighting the rapid evolution in this competitive class.
The Volkswagen Atlas excelled by delivering a well-rounded package with few weaknesses. It won nine of the 14 judged categories, a testament to its thoughtful design for modern families.
Based on our assessment experience, the Atlas’s combination of space, user-friendly tech, and family-focused features makes it the most compelling choice.
While the Atlas took top honors, the other competitors have specific strengths that may appeal to different buyer priorities.
The Chevrolet Traverse: The Cargo King The fully redesigned 2018 Traverse finished a strong second, blending minivan-like utility with SUV styling. Its biggest advantage is cargo capacity, offering the most space behind the third row in this test. The 3.6-liter V-6 engine was called the "best engine in the Challenge" for moving a large vehicle. However, it lost points for missing key active safety features like automatic emergency braking on the test vehicle and having less comfortable second-row seats.
The Honda Pilot: The Refined Contender The 2017 Honda Pilot, last year's winner, remains a strong option thanks to its exceptionally quiet and well-finished cabin. It features clever storage solutions, including a huge, washable center console bin, and a versatile underfloor cargo bin. Its major drawback is the optional nine-speed automatic transmission, which judges found hesitant and slow to respond, hindering the otherwise capable powertrain.
The Toyota Highlander: A Solid Two-Row Alternative The 2017 Highlander is a competent SUV, but it finished a distant fourth. Its smaller dimensions resulted in the least comfortable third row and the smallest cargo area. Its key advantage is that vital safety features like automatic emergency braking and lane-keep assist are standard on all trims. For families who only occasionally need the third row, the Highlander's strong safety story and comfortable front seats are worth considering.
Choosing the right three-row SUV depends heavily on your family's specific needs. Each vehicle in this test has a distinct personality and set of advantages.
Ultimately, the Volkswagen Atlas sets a new benchmark with its thoughtful design and family-friendly features, earning it the top spot in this competitive comparison.
